3.20.2008

On The Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness

I realized last fall why I like Andrew Peterson's music - imagery. You see, there are loads and loads of songs that are good and Christ-centered, but many seem to just say what they mean outright. AP has a tendency to write songs as a story is written. He doesn't just say what he means, but he shows it and so there's this depth that other songwriters simply don't show. So with that said, that is also why AP's book On the Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness is so enjoyable to read. He's a natural storyteller. The book is written with beautiful descriptions that carry me off into another world. I feel as though I'm immersed in Aerwiar and all I want throughout the day is to go back into that world and live, see, and feel the adventures of the Igiby children.

Before I get you too convinced about the wonderfulness of this book, I want to note one terrible point about it. Among the many footnotes (which I absolutely love) is one heart-wrenching footnote. This is what it reads:

"For as long as they could remember, Nia had taught the children what she called T.H.A.G.S. 1

1. Three Honored and Great Subjects: Word, Form, and Song. Some silly people believe that there's a fourth Honored and Great Subject, but those mathematicians are woefully mistaken."
What?! Am I a "silly person" who's "woefully mistaken"? I feel cut to the heart at this comment. I sure hope Nia's beliefs aren't a reflection of Andrew's personal beliefs because I literally gasped upon reading it. Three times. In fact, I was so troubled that I didn't know if I could go on reading. But then I realized that Andrew Peterson may never have known the art of mathematics growing up. I feel sorry for him if that is the case and especially sorry for the poor Igiby children who never get even a chance to know the art of mathematics. I digress to say that too many teachers take the beauty and intricacy of mathematics and chop them up and widdle them down until math is just a set of formulas and directions to be followed where not an ounce of joy can be found in it. Even Einstein himself has said,
"It is almost a miracle that modern teaching methods have not yet entirely strangled the holy curiosity of inquiry; for what this delicate little plant needs more than anything, besides stimulation, is freedom."
After contemplating these things, I continued on with my heart broken.

If you can get past that one issue, you will find a wonderful story about three Igiby children, their mother, their one-legged grandfather, Peet the Sock Man, the terrible Fangs, toothy cows and many other people and creatures. It's an exciting book that caused me to refrain from my work or homework and there are lots of little mysteries throughout the book that keep you wondering alongside Janner (the eldest boy).

Actually, I feel that I can't go on writing more since I'm not so great with words (I am a mathematician with apparently no honorable abilities) and I encourage you to read my friend Shannon's post(more blog post here). She says everything I want to with better words (and footnotes!!!). Oh, and if you comment on this post and on hers then you are put in a drawing for winning our giveaway books.

I read her post yesterday and finished the book late last night. And even so as I turned to the last page I found tears in my eyes quite unexpectedly. A wonderful story.

4 comments:

Kelsey said...

I couldn't believe it when your gmail status mentioned that AP had said math wasn't an honored and great subject. It is rather sad, isn't it...!

I'm glad, though, that you were able to forge on past that and make it to the end (although I'm not sure that I like that you *also* had tears in your eyes at the end of the book... what kind of book is this anyway?!).

Thanks for the review (and the advanced warning about the math comments)! :)

Unknown said...

Hey, my sister told me to comment on your review so that I could get a book. Actually, it was mostly so that she wouldn't get another free book, because she commented on several reviews of this book.
To be honest, I didn't really read your review. I read a few parts but not the whole thing.
I don't really like the guy's voice, but maybe I will like his book.

AmyD said...

Hey Josh..I'm sorry but a comment like that can't get you a book. The purpose of the free giveaway is to encourage people to comment on the book, ya know? Or what I wrote about the book, I suppose.

And I didn't particularly like AP's voice at first either. But after finally listening to the lyrics, their depth has moved me so much that I don't even think about his voice anymore. In fact, I'm convinced I like it just because the depth of lyrics. You should give him another try.

On second thought, if NO ONE comments anymore then I guess you (Josh) get the free book since Kelsey's already gotten one.

To all: if you are a reader who might like an adventure book, I suggest you comment to get yourself in the drawing for a free one.

Victoria in Flux said...

I love AP and his amazing ability to tell a story. I haven't read the book yet, but I am sure his math comment was in jest. It just seems to match his sense of humor. I have followed his music career and enjoy his limricks...Thanks for the review...I look forward to reading the book.